Why The Oakland Raiders Should Cut Carson Palmer

By Justin Allen
March 23, 2013 10:47 pm
1,822 Views 8 Comments

Palmer searches for an open receiver

Job security isn't usually a topic of thought for a team's most established player.  Aside from Oakland Raiders kicker Sebastian Janikowski, quarterback Carson Palmer has the most impressive resume of any member of the silver and black.

However, his name has been thrown around in recent months regarding his future in Oakland.

Palmer had a solid 2012 season.  He passed for 4,000 yards for the third time in his career and finished with an overall QB rating if 85.3.

According to Ian Rapoport of NFL.com, Palmer is "not sure what's going to happen, but he'd love to come back (to Oakland) and compete."

The “new era,” coined by Raiders general manager Reggie McKenzie hasn’t started well.  A team with high hopes going into 2012 came out of the season looking like the franchise of three years prior.

In 2013, Palmer will be owed $13 million by Oakland—who most recently cut Darrius Heyward-Bey, Michael Huff and Philip Wheeler as a salary dump.  It only makes sense if he is the next to go.

With former Ohio State quarterback Terrelle Pryor waiting in the wings, it's hard not to toy with the idea of inserting him as the starter immediately—especially on a team that is rebuilding.

If I’m Reggie McKenzie, I release Palmer immediately and begin to look further into the prospect of drafting West Virginia quarterback, Geno Smith.

Smith is an athletic passing quarterback whose skill set in college would translate well to the NFL.  The 6-foot-3-inch senior from Miami finished his college career with a QB rating of 163.9, according to ESPN.com.

The Raiders have the third overall pick in this year’s NFL draft, so why not use the pick on an important role player?  Palmer only has a few good years left in him anyways.

It would be a shame for the Raiders to eventually find their niche, only to start rebuilding again in the near future because their quarterback is too old.

At 33-years-old, Palmer is the third-oldest player on Oakland’s roster.  Both Janikowski and guard Cooper Carlisle are 35.

I’m surprised McKenzie hasn’t pulled the trigger yet.  Palmer is the reason why he had no first round pick to work with last year—and no second round pick this year. 


Learn how to get your FREE subscription to FFChamps via our partners DraftKings! FFChamps is the ONLY service with 1-on-1 Expert Fantasy Advice! SUBSCRIBE today!

submit to reddit

By Justin Allen
Become a fan

Leave a Comment

Previous Comments (8)

Please to post a comment.

2 years ago
first article in the off season about the raiders that makes any sense!!! thank you! i hope mckenzie is reading...
2 years ago

Thanks for the support!
2 years ago
I do think they need to dump Palmer but they need to give Pryor a shot and should not draft Smith
2 years ago

Smith would be nice to add depth. No need for another Tuiasosopo/Boller/Leinart as a 2nd stringer.
2 years ago

But you have to think smith will expect to start wherever he goes
2 years ago

He could very well start in Oakland. A competition between two young quarterbacks on a young team.
2 years ago

That wouldn't be a bad thing I guess
2 years ago
Terrell Pryor couldn't tote Carson Palmer's jock strap and if he were able he'd trade it for another tat. I think Tyler Wilson out of Arkansas is going to produce much better numbers in the NFL than Geno Smith. He had a nightmare season due to the coaching situation but was the leader of the team much more than the coaching staff and that says a lot about his on field character.

Connect With Us

Sign up for our newsletter to recieve all the latest news and updates...
Privacy guaranteed. We'll never share your info.