Eli vs. Peyton Manning: Move Over Big Brother

By Dave Holcomb
February 07, 2012 12:46 am
186 Views 4 Comments
Sitting at 6-6 and down by 12 with 5:41 remaining in the week 14 contest against the Dallas Cowboys, the New York Giants hardly looked like a championship team. Despite the odds, one Giant player never wavered: quarterback Eli Manning.

Manning drove his time quickly down the field to score a touchdown. Then, the Giants defense held the Cowboys to a three-and-out to get the ball back in Manning’s hands. Cool Eli rallied his team to another touchdown and two-point conversion to give New York a three point lead. Manning’s play and a blocked field goal on the last play of the game appeared to save New York’s season.

New York would fall the next week as they lost to Washington for the second time in 2011. At 7-7, New York was clinging to playoff hope, but Manning remained confident.

From there on, New York wouldn’t lose again. They beat the cross town rival Jets on Christmas Eve and defeated Dallas again to clinch the NFC East at 9-7. Surely, the Giants had a rough stretch in the middle of the season losing four in a row, but Manning took tremendous strides. As his defense struggled with injuries, Manning kept his team afloat with his 4,933 passing yards and 29 touchdowns. He truly proved his elite status in the NFL.

The Giants may have snuck into the playoffs but looked dangerous with Manning and a completely healthy defensive line. The defense sure helped as the cause as the Giants forced two safeties and gave up 14 points per game in their four victories to claim Super Bowl XLVI. Manning also passed for 1,219 yards, nine touchdowns and just one interception in the four games.

In the Super Bowl, the Giants again found themselves trailing with less than four minutes to play. Just like he did four years ago in Super Bowl XLII against the same foe, Manning was ultra-cool and drove his team down for the winning score. Not a field goal, Manning did it in style getting his team in the end zone.

Also like he did four years ago, Eli Manning won the game’s MVP. His second matches Patriots quarterback Tom Brady’s two Super Bowl MVPs. Eli Manning also has more Super Bowl rings and Super Bowl MVPs than his older brother, Peyton. That certainly raises the question, has Eli had a better career than his Peyton?

Peyton is certainly the king of the regular season; he has 54,828 passing yards, 399 touchdowns and a record of 141-67. But Eli, his baby brother, the man who wouldn’t play in San Diego, the guy who supposedly couldn’t handle the pressure of New York, has won more Super Bowls.

Maybe it’s too dramatic to put Eli’s career over Peyton’s so quickly. It could be argued that Peyton is the best quarterback of all-time. One thing is for certainly, however, Peyton is going to have to make some room on the family shelf for his little brother’s trophies.

Learn how to get your FREE subscription to FFChamps via our partners DraftKings! FFChamps is the ONLY service with 1-on-1 Expert Fantasy Advice! SUBSCRIBE today!

submit to reddit

By Dave Holcomb
Senior Writer
Become a fan

Leave a Comment

Previous Comments (4)

Please to post a comment.

3 years ago
People act like the Super Bowl counts for 5 seasons of mvp-level play. The regular season does count, 4 mvp's is impressive, and Peyton is far better than Eli. The Super Bowl has become wide open now, with a 10-6 and 9-7 winner the past two seasons. 12-4 used to be about as low as it got.
3 years ago

Thanks for the comment Joe. I think you're right. Four MVPs are very impressive, but I think Peyton would trade those in a heart beat for another Super Bowl ring.

And yea maybe record wise the Super Bowl winners are watered down, but looking at who the Giants had to play this season. The Packers played a few games without Rodgers last year. That explains why they each had lower records. Talent wise, they deserve to be Champions.
3 years ago

Yeah Peyton probably would make that trade. I'll be upfront and say that I am a huge fan of Peyton. I was going to UT the same time he was and have always liked watching him play. So. I'll always argue for him as one of the all-time greats and certainly as better than Eli.
I wouldn't say the 2011 NYG or 2010 GB Packers are as good as the 90's Coboys or 80's 49ers, but at least the games have been a lot better to watch recently. Growing up in the 80's it was just a matter of how badly the NFC would destroy the AFC every year. The games have been really entertaining for many of the past 15 years.
3 years ago
Personally, I would take either Manning in his prime from which to mold a championship team. Not sure I would pick Eli as the better OB just because he has two rings versus one for Peyton. The Giants arguably have had better defenses than the Colts in the past decade, plus the Colts probably played in the better conference until the past three years. Let's just hope Peyton comes back to play again so we can continure having this argument!!

Connect With Us

Sign up for our newsletter to recieve all the latest news and updates...
Privacy guaranteed. We'll never share your info.